|
|
Tue May 12, 2009 at 08:56:44 AM EDT
|
Prosecutors are rarely held accountable for acts of misconduct or abuses of power in our country. Yet another example of this reality comes from a case out of Florida, where prosecutors engaged in egregious, intentional courtroom misconduct throughout the trial. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals ultimately upheld the conviction in the case because they found that the misconduct did not affect the outcome of the trial.
The law provides judges with tools that guide them to weigh prosecutorial misconduct against the facts of a case to determine whether the misconduct was severe enough to affect the outcome of the trial. Regardless of what appellate courts decide (i.e., to uphold the conviction or remand it for retrial), the simple truth is that misconduct has occurred. Unfortunately, the system does not provide judges with tools to guide them on how to address acts of prosecutorial misconduct. While defense attorneys, fellow prosecutors, and judges are ethically obligated to report acts of misconduct by prosecutors to the proper disciplinary authority, this reporting rarely happens. When prosecutors do face disciplinary proceedings, meaningful sanctions are uncommon and rarely go further than a public censure.
As a result, prosecutors can predict how much misconduct will be tolerated by the system before a case even goes to trial. As long as the misconduct doesn’t prejudice the outcome of a trial to the point that a conviction is reversed, the misconduct will slip through the cracks and the prosecutor will not face any consequences. |
| JohnTerzano :: How Can We Hold Prosecutors Accountable for Misconduct? |
Many actors within the system recognize that prosecutorial misconduct in our nation’s courtrooms is a pervasive problem, and that prosecutors need to be held more accountable for abuses of discretion. In the Florida case mentioned above, Justice Ramirez stated in his dissenting opinion that, “over the years, it has been my unfortunate experience to see a long procession of assistant State attorneys repeatedly violate clear precedent in their zeal to convict.” He also makes clear his intention to publish the names of the prosecutors in the Southern Reporter—a rare move considering many judges often actively withhold the names of offending prosecutors from their published opinions.
Unfortunately, the prosecutors in the Florida case will likely face little or no punishment for their misconduct. As explained in The Justice Project’s recent publication, Prosecutorial Accountability: A Policy Review, when reviewing claims of prosecutorial misconduct, appeals courts must abide by the “harmless error” rule, in which a conviction must be upheld if the evidence against the defendant is strong enough—regardless of the misconduct committed by prosecutors. As a result, the convictions in the vast majority of prosecutorial misconduct cases are upheld, seldom resulting in reversals or modifications of convictions.
Appellate judges’ have their hands tied by the harmless error rule, and even if they do identify prosecutors by name, as Justice Ramirez intends to do in the Florida case, or report the misconduct, state disciplinary authorities typically do not effectively respond to prosecutorial misconduct.
Why not create mechanisms to hold prosecutors accountable for all acts of misconduct—harmless or not? The Justice Project’s policy review recommends jurisdictions establish prosecutorial review boards responsible for investigating all allegations of misconduct and imposing sanctions. In order to ensure the review board is aware of all allegations of misconduct, our policy review also recommends jurisdictions statutorily require trial and appellate judges to report acts of misconduct, regardless of whether the misconduct was deemed “harmless error.”
With such a review board in place, appellate judges like Ramirez in the Florida case would have the tools available to them to contribute to the process of holding prosecutors accountable by reporting them to an appropriate and effective disciplinary authority. Until prosecutors face the real threat of discipline, such as fines, suspension, or even disbarment, it is likely that the pervasive abuses of power and egregious acts of misconduct that exist in our criminal justice system will only continue.
John F. Terzano is President of The Justice Project, a nonpartisan organization that works to increase fairness and accuracy in the criminal justice system. |
|
Posts by citizen bloggers about Florida political issues.(Back to the top or jump to media "blog" posts)
If you have a product, drop us a line, and we'll take a look.(Back to the top, or jump to media posts or blog posts)
Please consider the following products and services:
Stuff made by folks with health insurance, pensions and daily overtime.
..........
Anyone can now make a Living Will and Health Power of Attorney free of charge at www.ItsMyLife.com by using the code TERRI ...........
Retro Campaigns - classic political T-shirts.
The exclusively endorsed website of the AFL-CIO Union Label & Service Trades Department and help millions of workers protect their jobs and ensure the security of their families.
(these are not paid ads, nor do we have any financial stake in any of these entities)
(Back to the top)
| Site News |
|
As of 7/16/10: An old friend resurfaces as BlogWood 2.0. Please check out the prolific Rantings from Florida and a new site, "Current news updates"
Immediately below, you can donate, follow select candidates on twitter, or check them out on Facebook. These are not paid ads.
Become a FLA Politics fan on and/or follow us on :
|
| Candidates |
The campaign web sites of select candidates; click on "FB" to check them out on FaceBook, "T" to follow them on twitter, and "$" to donate. These are not paid ads.
(Contact us for info)
Gov: Alex Sink $
Sen: Kendrick Meek $
Sen: Kevin Burns $
CD7: Heather Beaven $
CD8: Alan Grayson $
CD11: Kathy Castor $
CD2: Al Lawson $
CFO: Loranne Ausley FB T $
(Back to the top or jump to Florida netroots blog posts) or media "blog" posts)
- The Charlie Chronicles: Chain Gang Charlie wants to be a U.S. Senator. But how much do people know about Mr. Happy Face?
- "About 'Jeb!'" documents Jebbie Bush's background, and his record in politics and business.
- The outgoing RPOF U.S. Senator thinks he's an ""anti-family", "darling of homosexual extremists". What else don't we know about Billy McCollum?
- At "After All, He Is Black", we look at the inability of Florida "conservatives" to deal with racial issues.
- "Take this job ..." is a compendium of some of the things Florida employers are permitted to do to their employees.
Please leave comments or e-mail us with additional material for these projects.
Our collection of RSS feeds includes our selection of continuously updated Florida Netroots posts and Florida newspaper company "blog" posts, as well as a "Crist Watch" feed.
"blog" posts by employees of newspaper companies.(Back to the top or jump to Florida netroots blog posts)
| |
